What is Beyond a Reasonable Doubt (BRD)?

December 15, 2020

Guilty Beyond a Reasonable Doubt (BRD) is the standard for convictions in a criminal trial. A court cannot find that the defendant is guilty of a crime unless the evidence satisfies this standard of proof. But what exactly constitutes Beyond a Reasonable Doubt?

What is the Beyond a Reasonable Doubt?

Reasonable doubt occurs where the guilt of the accused falls short of absolute certainty. Where the preponderance of the evidence, or the lack of evidence presented, fails to clearly demonstrate the guilt of an individual reasonable doubt may exist.

Personal opinions or feelings are insufficient for reasonable doubt. To satisfy BRD the judge, or the judge and jury, must be more than sure, they must be closer to absolute certainty. There must be a very high probability of the defendant’s guilt. Based on reason and common sense that logically connects to the clear and convincing evidence. The Supreme Court of Canada said that reasonable doubt falls much closer to absolute certainty than to proof on a balance of probabilities.

The criminal law burden of proof that the prosecution must meet to satisfy beyond a reasonable doubt is much higher than the civil court standards of proof which is on the balance of probabilities. The balance of probabilities is not the highest standard of proof.

Alibi evidence that appears to show the defendant was elsewhere at the time of the criminal activity, for instance, may create reasonable doubt. 

Beyond a Reasonable Doubt

The Scale of Justice ensure that the standard of proof of Beyond a Reasonable Doubt.

How Beyond A Reasonable Doubt Works in Court

In a criminal trial, every person is presumed innocent until proven guilty. In a criminal case this puts the onus on the Crown to prove its case that the preponderance of the evidence supports the idea that guilt is the answer. In demonstrating this, they must prove that the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. If the Crown cannot satisfy beyond a reasonable doubt, there is no conviction.

Proof beyond a reasonable doubt, however, does not require absolute certainty, but it does mean more than probably guilty. Beyond a reasonable doubt does not mean without any doubt. The question that the Court must determine is, does reason and the supporting evidence suggest that guilt is more likely than not.

Evidence That Proves Guilt Beyond a Reasonable Doubt

The evidence in a criminal trial needs to be considered as a whole. The evidence on a whole needs to meet the standard of proof beyond a reasonable doubt. Individual pieces of available evidence do not need to meet the standard of proof  beyond a reasonable doubt. The Judge looks at the case as a whole, not as singular pieces of evidence. However, one piece of clear and convincing evidence may be enough to create reasonable doubt.

Just because one piece of evidence cannot be verified beyond a reasonable doubt does not dismiss other evidence. Not satisfying this requirement may not result in that piece of evidence being dismissed. Witness testimony, for example, is notoriously unreliable. Studies have proven that it’s extremely difficult for an eyewitness to accurately ID a person. As well as demonstrating that their memory is easily distorted or influenced. As such, it’s hard to consider unverified eyewitness testimony as providing evidence beyond a reasonable doubt. Yet, it continues to play an important role in criminal trials.

Reasonable Doubt Standard

If there is a question of guilty then that is a reasonable doubt.

A criminal lawyer is the best chance to ensure that the presumption of innocence is never lost and to have evidence challenged or dismissed. Whether challenging evidence that does not satisfy a BRD or applying for dismissal of illegally gathered evidence, your defence lawyer may be the difference in whether or not you are convicted.

Toronto Criminal Lawyer

Are you or a loved one facing criminal charges? Is there a risk that the presumption of innocence will be lost? A criminal lawyer is the best way to ensure that the evidence against you does not add up to the standard of proof BRD. William Jaksa is a Toronto criminal defence lawyer with expertise in challenging evidence. He will help you understand your charges, your options, and their potential outcomes. 

Contact William Jaksa today for your consultation.

Can You Be Convicted Without Evidence?

Related Articles

Jurisdictional Errors and Certiorari Applications

The scope of judicial review of certiorari is very limited, only allowing review where “it is alleged that the tribunal has acted in excess of its assigned statutory jurisdiction or has acted in breach of the principles of natural justice which, by the authorities is taken to be an excess of jurisdiction”. This limited scope of review reflects the limited screening purpose of the preliminary inquiry, only allowing review for jurisdictional error, and not mistakes of fact or law.

More Articles

Manslaughter Sentencing In Canada

Manslaughter Sentencing In Canada

Sentences for manslaughter convictions vary widely and can be difficult to understand. The Canadian criminal system is complex, with a range of possible consequences that depend on the circumstances associated with each specific case. This article will provide an overview of manslaughter...

read more
Criminal Harassment in Canada

Criminal Harassment in Canada

Criminal harassment is a criminal offence under the Criminal Code of Canada. It is also sometimes referred to as "stalking." Criminal harassment involves engaging in repeated, unwanted behaviour toward someone that causes that person to fear for their safety or for someone they know. Given that...

read more
Can Police Enter House Without a Warrant?

Can Police Enter House Without a Warrant?

Enter House Without Warrant In most cases police require a warrant to enter your house. However, police are allowed to enter your house, or enter private property, without a warrant in certain situations, such as when they have reason to believe that there is an life threatening emergency exists...

read more