BAIL HEARINGS AND BAIL CONDITIONS
After an accused person has been arrested and charged with a criminal code offence the arresting police officer may release that person from the scene or the police station. However, depending on the nature of the allegations, the accused’s personal circumstances and their criminal record, the police may decide to hold the person for a bail hearing within 24 hours.
Having an experienced criminal defence lawyer is important to securing a bail order with reasonable bail conditions. For over 15 years William Jaksa has been conducting contested bail hearings and bail reviews in Ontario. He is an experienced criminal lawyer that understands restrictive conditions or house arrest conditions are not always required to ensure compliance with a judicial interim release order. An effective bail supervision plan should focus on the personal circumstances of the accused person, the nature of the outstanding charges, on any safety concerns, and proposed supervision offered by one or more sureties. An accused person’s release on a bail order should be the normal outcome after a fair show cause hearing.
Unfortunately, often proposed sureties are unprepared for a contested bail hearing and often fail to adequately address the Crown’s concerns on one or more of the three grounds a judge or justice must assess when determining if an accused’s detention is necessary. Sometimes the sureties, even though honestly well-intentioned, are simply unacceptable for the role or responsibility. Other times the presiding justice finds that proposed supervision plan is inadequate for accused person’s unique circumstances. Failing to present one or more acceptable sureties or an acceptable proposed plan of supervision will result in a detention order and an accused person remaining in jail until their trial date or the matter is resolved. Being denied a release order will often increase legal costs, interfere with employment, limit a person’s defence options and create undue stress on a person’s family. Its important that a criminal lawyer is retained soon after a person’s arrest to provide legal advice and commence preparing a release plan and the sureties to testify in criminal court.
WHAT IS BAIL?
WHY HIRE A BAIL LAWYER IN TORONTO?
Experienced defence counsel will be able to assist in preparing a suitable supervision plan, preparing the proposed sureties to testify in court, and help organize the various documents required during a contested bail hearing. Not every bail hearing is the same. There is no one supervision plan that will work for every criminal charge. Bail hearings for domestic violence cases have a completely different set of considerations than a drug trafficking case or careless driving causing death case. Sureties will need to understand their role and responsibilities as they differ upon the criminal offences before the court.
WHAT IS A BAIL HEARING?
In the criminal justice system a show cause hearing, or more commonly referred to as a bail hearing, is a court proceeding that typically happens before a presiding Justice of the Peace to determine whether a person in police custody can be released. The Crown Attorney will advise of the allegations, the criminal code offences and explain the grounds on which they are seeking the person’s continued detention in jail. Defence counsel can call evidence through witnesses, present potential sureties and make submissions for accused’s release. Through the surety’s evidence defence counsel will demonstrate how the accused can be supervised on a bail order and the necessary condition that should be on that form of release. After all evidence and counsel submissions have been made a judge or justice will need to determine the form of release or order detention.
When deciding to release a person facing criminal charges the presiding justice must consider such factors including:
- EAre there Primary Ground concerns such as, will the accused attend their court date or are they a flight risk?
- EIs the person ordinarily resident in the jurisdiction?
- EIs a cash deposit necessary?
- EHow serious are the allegations? Is there a related prior criminal record?
- EIs there a history of complying with court orders?
- EWhat are the Secondary Ground concerns? What is the surety’s ability to supervise?
- EWhat is the strength of the Crown’s case? Is there a strong defence?
- EWill the accused continue committing the offence they were arrested on?
- EIs it possible they will commit other criminal code offences?
- EIs the alleged victim or the public in need of protection from the accused?
- EAny chance the accused will interfere with the witnesses?
- EFinally, are there any Tertiary Ground concerns?
- EIs the proposed supervision plan appropriate for this case?
- EWhat will the public think if the accused is released on bail?
- EWhat are the personal circumstances of the accused?
RESPONSIBILITIES OF A SURETY
The role of a surety is often referred to as a “civilian jailer”, which is to guarantee the good bahaviour of the accused person while they are on bail. They must ensure that the accused attends court when required, not commit any further crimes, and follow all the conditions of their bail order. During the bail hearing the court always wants to confirm that acting sureties are willing to accept the role and understand their responsibilities. That they understand the allegations and circumstances of the accused person, that they really know and understand the person they are supervising. Finally, that a surety knows how to “pull bail” and end their obligations. A bail hearing lawyer will be able to provide legal advice and assist a surety prepare for court and understand what is required for the bail plan.
In almost every Ontario Court duty counsel will be able to assist with minor cases and explain how a criminal proceeding works and other general information. Duty counsel services are provided by Legal Aid Ontario. They are often defence lawyers who work with legal aid that can help the family members of those with limited resources when they attend court. In many cases they are able to assist by negotiating with Crown Prosecutors the least restrictive bail conditions and sometimes a consent release for a minor criminal offence.
RECENT BAIL HEARING BLOGS AND ARTICLES
BY WILLIAM JAKSA
How to Bail Someone Out Jail?
Being released on a reasonable bail is extremely important in ultimately determining how a criminal case unfolds. Remaining in custody until trial affects how a criminal case is heard and has severe implications on an accused person's life and relationships. Being released on a reasonable bail...
COVID-19 Bail Hearing Decisions
While the Ontario Court of Justice and the Superior Court of Justice are being forced to adjust to the coronavirus pandemic by embracing the widespread use of telephone conference calls, video appearances and virtually courtrooms where all the participants are appearing remotely. The courts are...
Supreme Court Adds Life to 90-Day Reviews
The Supreme Court of Canada in Myers, 2019 SCC 18, just added new life and purpose to the 90-day detention reviews. The real question will be how the Courts and various Crown Attorney Offices react. This could easily mean many more section 525 reviews to ensure that people are not...
IMPORTANT SUPREME COURT OF CANADA DECISIONS ON BAIL HEARINGS
R. v. Antic,  1 S.C.R. 509